What would I / the Liberal Democrats have done differently with the Budget?

An emergency budget for tough times. Overall, although I was uncomfortable with some of the budget announcements there were few things in there I didn’t expect or which Labour would have done vastly differently. Cuts are needed, although timing is always questionable and to some degree it has been driven by the financial markets / ratings agencies (yes the same ones which thought Lehman Brothers was sound…).

I won’t cover what’s in there and how the Liberal Democrats have managed to get a few of our policies in the budget announcements, but rather to highlight the distinction between my party and the Conservatives I want to highlight what I would have done differently: 

  • I’m still uncomfortable with the £6bn cuts this year, given the need for public demand to fill the lack of private sector demand, this is a concern shared by the US, fuelled by the 1930s depression and the problems faced by Japan since the 1990s.
  • I would have kept child benefits rising year on year, but I would have withdrawn it from better off families via taxing of the benefit.
  • Invested more in capital projects such as green technology to kickstart the growth in the private sector which the Government is relying on.
  • Announced the renewal of trident to be included in the Strategic Defence Review to understand the potential for cost reduction.
  • Examined the case for road pricing along with investment in public transport (have the environmental costs fully accounted for).
  • Although I don’t want council tax increases, I would allow local authorities the ability to increase council tax if it’s needed to protect local services, many of the cuts will be at the local level due to tight budgets.
  • Look to increase the incentives to work via a greater personal allowance rather than just cutting back on benefits.
  • Not enforced the rule stating single parents must work when their child begins school, too broad brush and ignores the poverty trap.
  • Remove the winter fuel payments for pensioners.

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “What would I / the Liberal Democrats have done differently with the Budget?

  1. Philip Ling for Chancellor! You are right and GO is wrong (and very wrong) so all we said about him including those odorous comparisons with Vince were right! His budget is incompetent. My son has just joined the Labour party as a result and I am putting my energy into the resolution on Trident for the autumn conference. Check out Say No to Trident pages on Lib Dems Act if you want to join us, Phil. George Gregg has just joined and we are up to 181 membership on a members only site, which is not popular in the way that RATT was.

  2. We (or a group of Lib Dems) should publish what we had done in terms of the Budget if we had been the Government. A 100% Lib Dem Budget would look quite a bit different.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s