The dynamic and static analysis of the impact of the Budget

If you’re still with me, I’m referring to the report today by the IFS which is saying that the last Government Budget was “regressive”. However, the government (of which my party is part of) are arguing that the budget is “progressive” and the analysis by the IFS was “impartial”.

So who’s right?

Actually – as in statistics, both are.

The IFS is right to point out that there are benefit cuts and housing rule changes which will have a bigger impact for low income families, especially if they don’t work. They are also looking at the full impact up to 2014.

The Treasury’s work is looking only at the impact up to 2012, but more importantly it includes the dynamic impact of tax changes (increased income tax allowance, economic growth) to change the poverty trap so it makes it more worthwhile for those not working to work, which will improve income.

So comparing the two analysis is rather like comparing apples with pears. The IFS doesn’t assume any dynamic changes  and is over a longer period, but the Treasury does assume dynamic changes and over a shorter time frame.

For my previous comments on the Budget click here


One thought on “The dynamic and static analysis of the impact of the Budget

  1. Phil, Everyone is in favour of incentives to work and any steps to make it more financially rewarding to find employment can only be applauded but if unemployment is rising how can we expect all those who want to work to find suitable employment? I have not looked seriously at the new proposals re benefit yet but there could be some votes to be had for the good old Labour party if too much hardship is caused to the unemployed. Just sending as many asylum seekers and other immigrants home will not solve all our employment problems, I fear. Let`s hope the Gov`t has got it right or they will be accused of acting as if we were in the clutches of the IMF without actually being so. Janet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s